The Presidential Scoring Framework
Category 2 · Foreign policy & war
2.3

Diplomacy & soft power

All 16 modern US presidents ranked by their net score on this single sub-criterion. Good and harm are scored 0–10 independently; net is good minus harm. Click a name for the full scorecard.

01
Richard Nixon
Republican · 1969 – 1974
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Opening to China (February 1972 Beijing visit) ended 22-year diplomatic freeze. Detente architecture with USSR. Moscow Summit (May 1972). Era-defining diplomatic transformation.

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    Nixon's 1972 China visit ended 22 years of US-PRC diplomatic separation and reshaped Cold War strategic balance; among the most consequential diplomatic openings in 20th century US foreign policy.

    history.state.gov
+9/1
+8
02
Franklin D. Roosevelt
Democrat · 1933 – 1945
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Four Freedoms (1941) framing of war aims; Good Neighbor policy with Latin America (1933 onward, ended military interventions there).

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    FDR's Four Freedoms framing committed the US to a values-based postwar order that shaped UN Declaration of Human Rights.

    Four Freedoms speech (State of the Union, January 6, 1941)
+8/1
+7
03
Barack Obama
Democrat · 2009 – 2017
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

JCPOA Iran nuclear deal (2015). Paris Agreement (2015). Cuba normalization (2014-2016). Nobel Peace Prize (2009).

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    JCPOA, Paris Agreement, and Cuba normalization were three major Obama-era diplomatic achievements; JCPOA constrained Iran's nuclear program for 15 years; Paris launched modern climate-cooperation framework.

    history.state.gov
+8/2
+6
04
Jimmy Carter
Democrat · 1977 – 1981
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Camp David Accords (September 1978) — landmark Israel-Egypt peace deal. Human rights as foreign-policy framework. Panama Canal Treaties. SALT II signed (not ratified after Afghanistan invasion).

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    Camp David Accords produced first peace treaty between Israel and an Arab state, foundational to subsequent Middle East peace process.

    jimmycarterlibrary.gov
+8/2
+6
05
Harry S. Truman
Democrat · 1945 – 1953
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Berlin Airlift (June 1948-May 1949) — won propaganda victory of early Cold War without escalation. Truman Doctrine framing of free vs. unfree worlds. Recognized Israel (May 1948).

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Historical record·Unverified

    The Berlin Airlift delivered ~2.3 million tons of supplies over 277,000+ flights during Soviet blockade, breaking the blockade without military escalation — defining early-Cold-War soft-power victory.

    af.mil
+8/2
+6
06
George H.W. Bush
Republican · 1989 – 1993
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

START Treaty (1991), START II (1993). Madrid Conference (October 1991). Bush-Yeltsin relationship. Skilled professional diplomacy.

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    START Treaty reduced US and Soviet/Russian strategic nuclear arsenals substantially; Madrid Conference launched bilateral Israeli-Arab negotiations.

    history.state.gov
+8/2
+6
07
Ronald Reagan
Republican · 1981 – 1989
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Berlin Wall speech (June 1987). Reykjavik Summit (October 1986) nearly achieved abolition of nuclear weapons. INF Treaty. 'Evil Empire' speech (March 1983) provocative but combined with willingness to negotiate.

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    Reagan's rhetorical clarity combined with willingness to negotiate produced the most consequential US-Soviet diplomatic engagement since the early Cold War.

    reaganlibrary.gov
+8/2
+6
08
Dwight D. Eisenhower
Republican · 1953 – 1961
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Atoms for Peace (1953). Open Skies proposal (1955). People-to-People program. Geneva Summit (1955).

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    Atoms for Peace speech launched IAEA framework and reshaped global nuclear policy through civilian-use framing.

    iaea.org
+7/2
+5
09
John F. Kennedy
Democrat · 1961 – 1963
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Partial Nuclear Test Ban Treaty (signed August 1963). Peace Corps created (March 1961). USIA strengthened.

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    Limited Test Ban Treaty ended atmospheric nuclear testing by signatories; Peace Corps became enduring US soft-power institution.

    history.state.gov
+7/2
+5
10
Bill Clinton
Democrat · 1993 – 2001
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Oslo Accords (1993). Good Friday Agreement (1998). Camp David II (2000) failed. NPT extension. Strong soft power era.

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    Clinton brokered Oslo Accords (Israel-PLO) and Good Friday Agreement (Northern Ireland), two major peace processes; subsequent collapse of Oslo damaged legacy.

    history.state.gov
+7/3
+4
11
Gerald Ford
Republican · 1974 – 1977
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Helsinki Accords. SALT II framework drafted (signed under Carter). Vladivostok Summit (1974). Kissinger continuity.

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    Ford-Brezhnev Vladivostok agreement on strategic arms framework set up SALT II that Carter completed.

    history.state.gov
+6/2
+4
12
Joe Biden
Democrat · 2021 – 2025
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Restored to Paris Agreement, WHO, JCPOA negotiation attempts (failed). Hostage release deals (Trevor Reed, Brittney Griner, multiple Russia/Iran releases). Israel-Hamas damaged Middle East soft power.

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    Biden rejoined Paris Agreement on inauguration day; multiple successful hostage release negotiations; Israel-Hamas war (October 2023+) substantially damaged US standing in Global South.

    history.state.gov
+6/4
+2
13
Donald Trump (T1)
Republican · 2017 – 2021
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Abraham Accords (2020) — Israel-UAE/Bahrain/Morocco normalization (major success). Withdrew from Paris, JCPOA, WHO, TPP, INF Treaty, Open Skies. North Korea summits inconclusive. US soft power declined sharply.

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    Abraham Accords was major diplomatic achievement normalizing Israel with multiple Arab states; offset by major withdrawals from international agreements (Paris, JCPOA, WHO, TPP, INF, Open Skies, UNHRC).

    history.state.gov
+5/6
-1
14
Donald Trump (T2)
Republican · 2025 – —
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Withdrew from Paris Agreement again (Jan 20, 2025). Withdrew from WHO (Jan 20, 2025). USAID dismantled. State Department reorganization. Soft power substantially damaged.

low confidence
View 1 source
  • harm·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    Trump T2 immediately withdrew from Paris Agreement and WHO; USAID substantially dismantled with most programs terminated — major US soft-power retraction.

    Paris Agreement withdrawal EO January 20, 2025; WHO withdrawal EO January 20, 2025; USAID dismantling January-March 2025
+3/7
-4
15
George W. Bush
Republican · 2001 – 2009
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

'Axis of Evil' framing. Withdrawal from ABM Treaty 2002. Withdrew from Kyoto. North Korea diplomacy late-term. PEPFAR (HIV/AIDS) positive soft power.

View 1 source
  • harm·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    GW Bush framework rejected detente-era arms-control institutions and engaged adversaries through confrontational rhetoric; US soft power declined substantially during term per international polling.

    history.state.gov
+3/7
-4
16
Lyndon B. Johnson
Democrat · 1963 – 1969
0 agree · 0 disagreeSign in to react

Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty signed (July 1968). Otherwise diplomacy overshadowed by Vietnam. US international standing collapsed during term.

View 1 source
  • good·Tier 1·Primary document·Unverified

    NPT signed 1968 became foundational non-proliferation framework; one major diplomatic achievement in a term dominated by Vietnam.

    history.state.gov
+3/7
-4